Topics

Dick Cheney* will shoot your face
Texas Monthly magazine

Dick Cheney is often caricatured, and often in court defending the prerogatives of his office.

Featured Topic | Posted 29 weeks 1 day ago

Is Dick Cheney beyond the Constitution? Or just beyond Congress?

Vice President Dick Cheney has had a knack for stirring up constitutional controversy. Cheney asserted executive privilege and he's also argued that the vice president's office is outside the executive branch.

Read More

Ben likes: The executive's privilege

National Review

Typically, disputes like those over the U.S. attorney and terrorist-surveillance program are worked out by compromise. If a president wants to protect his prerogatives, he also wants to preserve a working relationship with Congress. But this particular relationship can’t be saved. Comity is impossible with a Congress bent on doing all it can to destroy what remains of the Bush administration. In the matter of the U.S. attorneys, the administration has provided Congress 8,500 pages of documents and numerous officials and former officials have testified. This isn’t enough for a Congress that won’t stop until it has run-down every outlandish conspiracy theory about the firings that -- even if clumsy and ill-advised -- were perfectly within Bush’s power to make.

And so, the administration was justified in saying both, "no more," and "see you in court." There, it can hope to get a decision that strengthens the executive’s ability to protect its deliberations for a long time to come.

Read More

Joel likes: Cheney and the Constitution

Aziz Huq/The Nation

For Cheney to be pushing the envelope on executive power is especially ironic, given the original constitutional status of the vice presidency: That office is a vestigial afterthought tacked on to the Constitution toward the end of the 1787 Constitutional Convention to solve a gaggle of unrelated problems. And it quickly proved more trouble than it was worth.

The vice presidency, in short, was never intended as an independent center of constitutional power--let alone home of a shadow EPA (the rather wonderfully named White House Council on Environmental Quality); the secret architect of national energy policy; and the shameful global detention and torture policies--including the wretched military commission system.

Perhaps we do need to start thinking about why perhaps the most powerful office in the country is not on the top of a ballot, and why its powers are not defined -- or circumscribed -- by any law or constitutional provision.  It's long past time for Congress to take this on. Past legislation has further provided clear channels of responsibility, particularly on military matters. It would be a good debate to have before the 2008 election, when Cheney will start opening the envelopes.

Read More

How readers are voting

your vote
average
vote
The Associated Press

"Harold and Kumar" stars Kal Penn (right) and John Cho yuk it up at a panel discussion at the SXSW Film Festival in March.

Featured Topic | Posted 29 weeks 6 days ago

Harold and Kumar opens: Is America ready for Guantanamo jokes?

Anti-war films tank at the box office. Hollywood has produced bomb after bomb (so to speak) and the bombs keep coming. Will one ever hit? Well, maybe this time at pair of stoners will be just the remedy Tinsel Town needs to attract an audience and make money. Ready or not, Harold & Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay hits theaters as mainstream Hollywood's first comedy to lampoon the United States' war on terror.

Read More

Ben likes: Remix of an Olbermann rant

Libertas

The best part of the review comes at the end when Variety describes the film as, “one of the ballsiest comedies to come out of Hollywood in a long time” — proving only that Variety needs to get out more. Maybe a field trip to Wal-Mart, or something. Ballsy? If there’s a finer resume enhancer in Hollywood than trashing America and the people who defend us, I’m unaware of it.

Try to imagine in the thick of World War II, Bob Hope making a film ridiculing our side. Good heavens, even a leftie like Charlie Chaplin had the moral compass to ridicule Hitler instead of Roosevelt and Churchill.

But don’t get the wrong idea. No one’s questioning anyone’s patriotism here.  

Read More

Joel likes: Absurdistan

Anthony Kaufman/Village Voice

Earnest, sad, and righteous, they are not. More inspired by M*A*S*H or Dr. Strangelove than The Deer Hunter or Coming Home, a new pack of political films that defy the clichés of the post-9/11 Iraq War cinema has arrived. Rife with satire and absurdity, with more ambiguity and less agit-prop, they don't toe the MoveOn party line and go beyond the familiar war-is-hell mantra. As documentary filmmaker Michael Tucker says: "Yes, it's tragic and horrible. Duh. What else is there?"

For one, there's the bizarre madness of it at all, as shown in Harold and Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay. While ostensibly a raunchy teen comedy, the film's archvillain is a racist, ignorant deputy chief of Homeland Security who sends Harold and Kumar to face the horrors of Gitmo. "While it's obviously absurd," co-writer-director Hayden Schlossberg acknowledges of the film's premise, "there's an element of truth. There have been people thrown in Guantánamo who have done nothing. We like the idea of doing something about these subjects in a way that's not serious."

"Sincerity handicaps you," explains Tucker, who co-directed a number of Iraq docs, including Gunner Palace. "Trying to be earnest about something—it does nothing to explain it," he says. "That's why the fiction films have largely failed—because people are already in that emotional place." 

Read More

How readers are voting

average
vote
Gitmo
The Associated Press

A guard stands duty at Guantanamo Bay's prison fo rsuspected terrorists.

Featured Topic | Posted 31 weeks 3 days ago

Is it time to shut down Guantanamo Bay prison?

A wave of change appears headed toward the U.S. detention center at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, with all three major presidential candidates vowing to abolish the military prison. And somewhat surprisingly, closing the camp and moving the prisoners to the United States may be the easy part, said U.S. officials, former administration aides and legal experts. But nobody has yet found a way through the legal thicket in the way.

Read More

Ben likes: What follows Gitmo

Ed Morrissey/Hot Air

Closing Gitmo takes no effort at all, but that's only the beginning -- and it reveals that the real issue has never been Guantanamo Bay at all. The real issue, one all three presidential candidates have avoided, is whether we release known terrorists and allow them the opportunity to attack us again.

In closing Gitmo, we have two choices. One would be to ship the detainees to another detention facility outside of the U.S., which would only be a geographical change. It would win us nothing in terms of international approval, and would likely be much less secure than Gitmo. The second choice would be to bring the detainees to the U.S. and either use the civilian courts or get Congress to approve indeterminate detention without trial inside the U.S. -- essentially recognizing the danger the terrorists pose and treating them like we treat them now at Gitmo, using military tribunals instead of courts.

Again, this would only be a change in location, and hardly a salutary one at that for Americans.

Read More

Joel likes: Beyond Guantanamo

Jonathan Hafetz/The Nation

Let's start by stating the obvious: Guantánamo is not just a prison. It is an entirely new kind of penal institution that perfectly embodies the Administration's new paradigm for a never-ending, ubiquitous "war on terror."

At Guantánamo, individuals are held indefinitely as "enemy combatants," a term that conjures images of captured enemy soldiers. In fact, the government's own data shows that the majority of prisoners at Guantánamo never took up arms against the United States or engaged in hostile conduct toward this country. The cells at Guantánamo are full of civilians, many of whom were seized in places like Bosnia and Gambia, thousands of miles from any battlefield.

As they seek to repair the damage and recast the future, America's leaders should look beyond Guantánamo and remember the commitment to justice that made this country great for more than two centuries. The question is not whether America should imprison terrorists. It is whether America will treat all accused persons consistently with its Constitution and values.

Read More

How readers are voting

average
vote
The Associated Press

Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the alleged mastermind of 9/11.

Featured Topic | Posted 40 weeks 3 days ago

Six charged in 9/11 attacks

More than seven years after the attacks, The Pentagon has charged six detainees at Guantanamo Bay with murder and war crimes in connection with the Sept. 11 attacks. The defendants face the death penalty.

What will the trials look like? Should there be trials at all?

Read More

Ben likes: Tough times for al-Qaida

John Hinderaker/Powerline

If these terrorists have exhausted their usefulness as sources of intelligence, the course most consistent with military history would be to shoot them. But we are far down the path of giving lawyers priority over soldiers in fighting the war against the jihadists.

Read More

Joel likes: Pentagon scrambling to line up defense

Carol Rosenberg/The Miami Herald

The military was scrambling Monday to put together defense teams for the six Guantánamo captives singled out by a Pentagon prosecutor for death-penalty eligible charges alleging they conspired to kill thousands in the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks.

"I will move as quickly as I can, but we will take our time and we will not be bullied by the government," said Army Col. Steve David, Chief Defense Counsel in the Office of Military Commissions. David, an Indiana state judge who was mobilized to the job, said at a bare minimum he needed six lawyers, six paralegals and six independent investigators with top security clearances to work on the trials.

As of Monday morning, he said, he had a sum total of seven military lawyers assigned to his office.

Read More

How readers are voting

average
vote

Join the Debate

Start your own blog, comment on topics, and let your voice be heard. Start your free account now!

User login

login

Most Viewed

Most Discussed

Most Emailed

Ads by Google