Let's build schools in the Middle East
Posted 22 weeks 4 days ago byI always get a little dizzy when this happens, but let me endorse this idea from today's Washington Times:
The madrassa movement is the establishment of schools dedicated to teaching the Koran by memorization. It teaches no marketable skills, and most graduates come out largely illiterate except for memorization and jihadist indoctrination. They are brainwashed candidates for the suicide-bombing program. In many poor Muslim countries, it is the only form of education that they will receive. In many areas, it is the only choice a parent has because it is available and free.
Put yourself in their shoes; you are a young man with no job prospects and no education. You have no chance of attracting a wife. You are promised a ticket to paradise. What would you do? The question for us is, "how do we counter it?" Closing the schools is not the answer. The governments involved would only make martyrs of them or drive them underground; we need antibodies. We need positive ideas to counter this nonsense. To date, we have been using the combination of carrots and sticks to try to force our will on a culture that we do not well understand. I have run this idea through a number of respected Muslim-American scholars; they think it has potential. We should fund a series of academies in each locality where a madrassa school exists. Its curriculum would be two pronged. Mornings would teach the three "Rs." Afternoons would be devoted to some kind of vocational training such as masonry, electrical work, and carpentry. The graduates would come out being able to read and write along with a marketable skill.
Will this cost money? Sure. But tanks and weapons systems tend to be more expensive than a teacher, so we might come out ahead. And we might end up with allies instead of enemies.














Thoughts
Not a New Idea
Submitted on April 1st, 2008 by AnonymousBuilding American style schools in Islamic countries is not a novel idea. Even Syria has some American style schools.
As far as trying to prevent hostility, what I personally saw in Iraq was the building of schools with American influence with the support of the local clerics. This allows for community support of the school and a more advanced curriculum than previous schools had allowed. The side benefit was that young girls were able to participate as long as we built a separate school. A large number of schools were run by people that were trained in the US or Europe that had returned after Saddam was removed.
Maybe if we use the lessons we learned in Iraq on education, we could expand it to other regions, such as Sudan or Somalia?
I'm not convinced.
Submitted on April 1st, 2008 by Evan McLarenI wonder if we ought automatically to speak of such ideas so hopefully as "possibilities" that we haven't tried yet. There is a wealth of scholarship suggesting that public education has been quite a costly and in some ways decivilizing institution, in the U.S. and elsewhere. Similarly, there is plenty of work showing how the public administrators who carry out these programs have a habit of doing so in a less than value-neutral manner--one might recall the social planners grouped around the New Republic in the '20s and '30s who quite explicitly viewed their work in public education and managerial politics as corroding older patterns of bourgeois society that they disliked. It also bears consideration how our current phase of public philosophy, multiculturalism, would fair in an unstable Middle Eastern setting.
Is it not also naive to speak solely in terms of schools and education? I find it impossible to imagine that such schools could remain standing without heavy military protection. With that fact alone the cost and logistical complexity of this proposal multiply--probably to the satisfaction of political forces interested in seeing the U.S. remain heavily committed to the area in perpetuity.
That's a good question
Submitted on April 1st, 2008 by JoelI think that's a real danger, too, that such schools would be seen as propaganda instead of education. A light touch would be required. But right now there is almost no competition for a lot of these schools. And we haven't really tried yet. It might fail. But it might not, and it seems a worthy experiment.
Would they be responsive?
Submitted on April 1st, 2008 by AnonymousWouldn't they just consider any US opened schools anti-Islamic propaganda, or would this work in conjunction with the Madrassa schools?
I'm a firm believer that poverty and lack of education are main drivers for suicide bombers and other terrorists.