Eggheads in politics: A combustible mix
Posted 36 weeks 6 days ago byOne of the best-ever episodes of "The Simpsons" came in 1999, when Lisa and other members of the Springfield Mensa club took over the town -- and, predictably, made a disaster of it. Luckily, in the end, physicist Stephen Hawking swooped down in his helicopter-powered wheelchair to deliver a lecture about humility.
This prompted one of the best Homer Simpson lines of all time: "Larry Flynt is right!"
On a related note, you may have heard that Barack Obama adviser Samantha Power (left) resigned from the campaign today after calling Hillary Clinton a "monster" in an interview. Power, a Harvard professor, has written powerfully about genocide, so she presumably knows who the real monsters are -- nonetheless, she made an unwise comment, and sacrificed herself to limit the controversy to one news cycle.
(We will leave, for the moment, the question of why the Clinton campaign is making such a fuss about a thoughtless comment when it is quite deliberately making ads that darken Obama's skin. We will, however, offer up a thought experiment: What do you think the initial reaction in the Clinton camp was when they heard about the "monster" comment? Anger or glee?)
This, of course, comes a few days after another Obama adviser, economist Austin Goolsbee, apparently told the Canadians that Obama was just joshing with all that anti-NAFTA talk -- and maybe handed the Ohio primary to Clinton as a result.
Power and Goolsbee are, by all accounts, very smart people. But it's clear that they're not politicians.
Let's clarify: They might be very smart about politics. But clearly they aren't very good at politics.
This isn't a bash-them-eggheads post. It's good to have smart people working for a campaign. But unless you know they're good at politics, it's probably best to keep them quiet and behind the scenes.
Samantha Power photo from AP.














Thoughts
well...
Submitted on March 8th, 2008 by JoelIt has been a rough week for the Obaminator. But I think most campaigns - winners and losers - end up with weeks like this on the trail. Given that it's six weeks until the next very important primary (Pennsylvania) there's time to recover.
Obama's Poor Judgement
Submitted on March 8th, 2008 by AnonymousObama seems to have poor judgement in his selection of advisors!
Top Obama Foreign Policy Advisor Says He's Not Ready To Answer The Phone At 3AM
Send to a Friend »
Susan Rice, Sen. Obama's top foreign policy advisor, today acknowledged that Sen. Obama is not ready to answer the phone at 3AM as President. Watch the video:
Hillary is ready to take the 3AM phone call and is ready to be commander-in-chief on day one. That's why nearly 30 general and flag officers have endorsed Hillary Clinton to be the Nation’s next President.
Transcript:
RICE: "Clinton hasn't had to answer the phone at three o'clock in the morning and yet she attacked Barack Obama for not being ready. They're both not ready to have that 3AM phone call.
3/5/2008 7:
I prefer street smarts in my politicians
Submitted on March 7th, 2008 by ansuyoHa, amen to that! Yes, there is a big difference between knowing about politics and being political. Personally, I think the first better than the last, but then I'm not all that good at the doing part of politics.
I think we're paying way to much attention to peoples missteps of the tongue. Good grief!
Helium.com Home Page