Ben

Obama's "progressive" reading of the Bible

Yes, it's a dangerous mix, religion and politics. Barack Obama, for example, reads the New Testament and finds an implicit endorsement of civil unions. (But not, Obama insists, gay marriage.) "If people find that controversial then I would just refer them to the Sermon on the Mount, which I think is, in my mind, for my faith, more central than an obscure passage in Romans," Obama said Sunday. (Here's a transcript.)

Obama was undoubtedly referring to everybody's favorite quotation from Jesus, the New Testament's get-out-of-perdition-free clause in Matthew 7: "Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you."

This is, as Joe Knippenberg points out, a "typical liberal theological move, finding proof texts that support his preferences while dismissing passages whose import he doesn’t like." I fully endorse this view. In progressive theology, as in constitutional law, it's all about those "penumbras and emanations."

The Atlantic's Marc Ambinder, however, thinks such sermonizing is bad form in just about any political context. "Obama's reference was casual, and in referencing scripture he's committed the same (venial) sin that liberal religionists are always cataloguing as coming from conservatives: that they slip contextless biblical phrases into their political stump speeches and degrade the meaning of both."

Meantime, Biola University philosophy professor John Mark Reynolds has a fairly convincing take down of Obama's liberal interpretation of scripture. "By bringing a Biblical argument regarding civil unions (Obama thinks Jesus is for them!), into a discussion full of folk who do not read the Bible, Obama ignores the wisdom of Paul in the first chapter of Romans. Paul points there to the existence of a common natural philosophy available to Christians and non-Christians. This allows for a civil society that need not be based on revelation available only to believers."

"Nothing is left to restrain a liberal who will read a book or document in this manner," Reynolds concludes. "Obama finds what he needs in the Constitution or Scripture and so the rule of law in the state and in the church is endangered."

It's tough to disagree.