Ben

Dumbest product bans ever

There are reasonable regulations, and then there is this: In Louisiana, it's illegal to arrange two or more different types of flowers without a state florist license. Silly, right? In Virginia, it's illegal to sell Sangria, a mixture of wine, brandy and fruit. Ridiculous. But wait, there's more!

The Competitive Enterprise Institute just released a report detailing five of the "dumbest product bans ever." Louisiana's flower rules and Virginia's preposterous Sangria ban make the list, along with three far more serious contenders. (The summary is here, but the the full report (in PDF) is well worth reading.)

Some product bans make sense: kiddie porn, for example, or the private ownership of weapons of mass destruction. But other bans make no sense, and often exist either to protect special interests (Big Florists, in the case of the Louisiana law) or to serve some dubious social purpose. Those bans limit consumer choice, stifle innovation and generally offer a patina of protection.

It's possible to argue with CEI's picks, as author Eli Lehrer acknowledges at the outset: "By necessities of space and brevity, many delightfully absurd product bans remain unexplored here." Sounds like a franchise is born.

Join the Debate

Start your own blog, comment on topics, and let your voice be heard. Start your free account now!

User login

Ads by Google