Should the war on obesity trump the war on terrorism?
Posted 45 weeks 2 days ago byWhat happens when experts take cost-benefit analysis too far? You get stories like this one: "Obesity more dangerous than terrorism."
Now, on one level, that's entirely correct. Odds are, a sedentary, overweight American is more likely to die of a heart attack than perish in a terrorist attack. Chronic disease will kill an estimated 388 million people worldwide over the next 10 years, Georgetown health law professor Lawrence Gostin told the fifth annual conference of the Oxford Health Alliance on Monday.
On the other hand, so what? Gostin might have also noted how hundreds of millions more people will die from old age, congenital birth defects, automobile accidents, drowning, falling down stairs, skateboarding, and, oh, I don't know, boredom maybe.
But the question is one of priorities. Should governments spend more on eradicating terrorism or on programs aimed at encouraging people to eat better and exercise more? Incredibly, the people at the Oxford Health Alliance conference seem to favor the latter.
"Ever since September 11, we've been lurching from one crisis to the next, which has really frightened the public," Gostin said. "While we've been focusing so much attention on that, we've had this silent epidemic of obesity that's killing millions of people around the world, and we're devoting very little attention to it and a negligible amount of money." The point? Far better, evidently, for the state to scare people healthy rather than "scare" people about "terrorism," which, while a "threat," does not pose nearly so great a danger as overeating and smoking.
Well, that's nonsense, and insulting nonsense, too. Terrorism might kill fewer people, but it is far more disruptive of our lives and liberties than poor lifestyle choices could ever be.














Thoughts
Childhood Obesity......
Submitted on December 1st, 2008 by AnonymousObesity is one of the major health problems we are facing now. One thing that we can do is to raise public awareness about this kind of public health threat. If this cannot be solve immediately it can give us a devastating effect on one’s health. The American mantra is cheap convenience, and fast food restaurants embrace that mantra. The increased consumption of fast food has fueled the American obesity epidemic, and America is the fattest it has ever been. A healthy diet as well as regular physical activities is a great help to combat obesity. American families would be better off eating healthier, more nutritious foods found at the grocery store. However, many American families cannot afford the wholesome foods at the grocery store. While eating has become a sort of an epidemic, eating healthily has become a luxury in the United States. Even though healthy foods are expensive, your health, the health of your family, and the health of the world food supply are worth the extra cost. It can be tempting to indulge on fast food on a daily basis, especially when your budget is tight and the value menu is calling your name. Plus, a grocery bill can seem like a big expense. That’s why when you need to feed your family healthy food you can count on fast payday loans to help cover grocery expenses until your next payday. Click to read more on Fast Payday Loans.
Simply put? Absolutely not!
Submitted on February 27th, 2008 by AnonymousTo compare the "battle of the bulge" to the war on terrorism is ludicrous. I can hardly believe anyone would even try.
As for the "war" on obesity? Thank the government for adding growth hormones to our food supply. Thank the government for eliminating physical education and sports from our educational systems. Thank the government for making it nearly impossible to feed your family healthy food because of the expense. There is something grossly wrong when a mother can buy a 2 liter bottle of Coke for 99 cents but a gallon of milk costs $3.98 (that is what I paid just today!)
I can't disagree with the information put forth by Mr. Johnson but I do think that the problem is much larger (no pun intended) than what is described.
The Scare tactics of the anti-fat lobby
Submitted on February 26th, 2008 by Chuck_JohnsonEven if we were to assume that there actually were such a thing as the War on Fat and that we could win it, it's less than clear we've had any affect at all. See this piece from reason.
Okay.. that's just bunk
Submitted on February 26th, 2008 by Chuck_JohnsonThe standards have changed so much for what the military takes or doesn't take. Those standards fluctuate all over the place as anyone who was drafted in Vietnam can attest.
That's also assuming that back in World War II people were more fit than they are now. Standards for assessing B.M.I has also changed and there's some doubt that we should even be using B.M.I. in the first place.
Terrorism and Obesity should never be in the same category
Submitted on February 26th, 2008 by ansuyoWow, the world really has turned upside down hasn't it? I think I'm almost speechless at the absurdity of some people's thinking.
1) I'm so tired of hearing about the obesity epidemic -- instead of looking at cause and effect, they've already made up their mind and are causing more problems than they are helping with the scare campaign.
2) Obesity is NOT the same thing as Terrorism, and it certainly doesn't trump it. I know that's not exactly what they're saying, but it's close.
I guess if we forget about terrorism and focus on obesity, we can have thin, healthy people for Al Qaeda to kill. Terrorists are out to destroy America, fat or not.
Actually . . .
Submitted on February 25th, 2008 by KansasGirlWhat's funny is, they're almost right. I've been reading the recently released report by the Congressional Commission on the National Guard and Reserves (400 pgs, don't ask me to summarize), and one thing that caught my eye was this:
"DOD estimates that more than half the youth in the U.S. population between the ages of 17 and 24 do not meet the minimum requirements to enter military service. Approximately 22% of America's youth exceed the limits set for enlistees' body mass index."
So maybe obesity isn't more dangerous than terrorism, but it's certainly a huge factor in our ability to fight it. Who knew?